How to Ask an Alumni Group for Industry Advice
An alumni group can help you see how different paths work. Give enough context to get comparable answers and leave each person free to share what they know.
Ask the group
I’m moving from classroom teaching into learning design. For alumni who made that move, what did you include in your first portfolio that interviewers asked about?

I switched from teaching to learning design and used a short onboarding module as my sample.
Thanks. Did you build it from scratch, or adapt something you had permission to share from class?
Ask a question several alumni can answer from experience
If the goal is career information, focus on a transition and the decisions alumni actually made. Ask for one example of how they handled it. Narrow details such as the first project they published or first interview question provide more useful replies than asking for a complete roadmap.
Search the group for earlier answers first. Summarize what you’ve tried and avoid asking members to disclose restricted project material. If you receive several useful replies, close the thread with a brief thank-you.
Turn a broad career question into one alumni can answer
- Write down a choice you need to make, such as which project to put first in a portfolio.
- Ask for one decision someone made during a similar transition.
- Check whether the question can be answered from one example without sharing a private employer or student record.
Keep referral requests separate from experience questions. A person who answers an advice thread has agreed to answer that question, and can choose whether they want further contact.
Check previous group discussions first and mention one thing you have already tried. If another person offers a portfolio sample privately, avoid asking them to share restricted student or employer materials. Close the public thread with a general takeaway if it helps future readers.
Follow up respectfully
Thanks for sharing that. If you’re comfortable saying, did you use a work example or create a new sample?
What should you do with advice you get in a private reply?
Ask before quoting someone or sharing their sample in the alumni group. You can usually thank the people involved and share your own general takeaway without naming a person or exposing their details. Separate the public discussion from any private referral or mentoring that follows.
Join the Discussion
Sign in with your Google account to leave a comment under this article.
Comments
Join the Discussion